Workflow for Seeking Core Curriculum Element
A strong Core Curriculum depends on the expertise and innovation of individual faculty members and on the participation of faculty across the curriculum. The Core element approval process exists to ensure consistency in students’ experience across the Core Curriculum, as well as the assessibility of the Core Curriculum.
The purpose of these guidelines is to clarify expectations for courses participating in the Core Curriculum and to make the process of acquiring a Core element as straightforward as possible. You should feel free to request assistance or clarification from the Chair of the Core Curriculum Committee or the Associate Provost of the Core Curriculum as you prepare your proposal.
Policies related to Core Curriculum approvals can be found here.
Step 1
On the EPC proposal form, select one of the following to trigger a review by the Core Curriculum Committee:
- Add permanent Core course
- Add Core Element to existing course
- Add Core Element to Special Topics course
Step 2
Complete the Core Element Approval Worksheet. Key things to remember:
- You must explain which element(s) the course will meet. If you are requesting more than one element for a single course, please carefully explain each (or submit the worksheet twice).
- You must explain how the course delivers the outcomes tied to any assigned core element(s).
- You must explain the assignment (or assignments) you will use to evaluate individual student learning for each assigned outcome. To ensure you’re seeing a student’s best and most invested work related to the learning outcome, the assignment should amount to at least 15% of the course grade and must be carefully integrated into the course design. If you use multiple assignments to evaluate distinct LOs, you should explain each assignment and assignments altogether should constitute 15% of the course grade. Note: in an alternative grading system you must use a non-optional assignment that roughly equals 15% of the course assessment.
Step 3
Include documentation with your EPC proposal. The CCC requires
1) the completed Core Element Worksheet;
2) a draft of the course syllabus, and
3) a draft of the assignment prompt(s) referenced in your Core Element Worksheet.
In the syllabus, be sure to list the Learning Outcomes for the element(s) you are requesting and indicate to students how/where in the course those LOs will be assessed.
Any proposal lacking the documentation of these three items will be returned as incomplete.
Tips and Strategies for Completing the CCC Core Element Request Worksheet
As part of your EPC proposal you’ll need to submit the CCC Core Element Request Worksheet for any element(s) you are requesting to be added to a new or existing course. The tips and strategies below will help you plan an approach to the worksheet.
We use several methods to assess the quality of our Core Curriculum. One of the most prominent is the direct scoring of student artifacts using a common rubric (rubrics can be found here-forthcoming). While faculty are not required to use these rubrics when teaching Core courses, the rubrics do help us identify benchmarks for student learning such that we can evaluate, however generally, whether or not students are learning what we want them to learn in Core courses. Artifact scoring takes place at the end of the year. Scoring is completed by faculty members who teach courses that count for the element being assessed. Importantly, these faculty members understand the outcomes very well but may not necessarily be content-area experts.
An effective assignment for general education assessment is going to meet several criteria:
- It is as discrete as possible, meaning it doesn’t ask students to demonstrate a huge number of skills/content areas. Rather, it focuses their attention on the learning outcomes.
- It is clearly aligned to the Core learning outcomes.
- It usually comes from the end of a course, meaning it demonstrates each student’s best and most invested opportunity to show their learning in each LO area. Note: an assignment could be placed earlier in the course if it is the “culmination” of learning related to the particular LO.
- It carries substantial value in the course, ensuring that it reflects the student’s most committed work (per the worksheet, the assignment(s) must constitute at least 15% of the course grade and must be a required course assignment). Note: in an alternative grading system you must use a non-optional assignment that roughly equals 15% of the course assessment.
- It provides students with an opportunity to show their own learning rather than group learning.
- It asks students to create their own product as much as possible; avoid worksheet-based assignments where they simply fill in blanks or provide correct answers.
As you plan your assignment, consider what you want the assessment to demonstrate: growth over time or a single snapshot of student learning. Developmental or growth-oriented assignments would include portfolios, early/late drafts, projects with reflections, or anything that includes multiple demonstrations recorded over time (or accounts of learning over time). Snapshots of student learning would include individual papers or posters, exam questions, or anything that simply demonstrates learning proficiency at the moment at which the assignment was completed.
Be sure the students know what you are measuring. Make the Core learning outcomes a clear and specific part of the course, the assignment, and the assignment grade. Help your students understand the skills you are expecting them to demonstrate.
How does CCC read these worksheets?
The CCC poses several questions when reviewing any proposal for a new Core Curriculum requirement.
- First: does the worksheet and accompanying syllabus list the element and LOs delivered in the course?
- Second: does the worksheet and accompanying syllabus outline how the course delivers each LO? These LOs should be central to the course, accounting for a significant portion of the course material. They should not be added on to make a content area course count for general education.
- Third: does the worksheet introduce a primary assignment that will be used to measure learning for each learning outcome?
- Fourth: does the worksheet carefully explain, to a non-specialist, how the assignment will demonstrate learning for each learning outcome?
- Fifth: does the worksheet specify the percentage of the student’s grade that will be earned from the assignment(s) that will measure each LO?
We recommend you use this proposal process as an opportunity to think through your plans for teaching and assessing student learning in each LO area. This shouldn’t be a best guess; rather, it should reflect clear and specific plans for how the course will promote learning in each outcome area.